Pizzeria ProConnect

In-house delivery or delivery platforms: which should you choose?

Delivery can become a real source of additional revenue for a pizzeria, but it also changes the way the business is organised, how costs are managed and how the customer relationship works. There are two main options: managing deliveries yourself with your own drivers or using specialised delivery platforms.

There is no single best solution for every pizzeria. The right choice depends on your order volume, delivery area, production capacity, organisation and, above all, the real profitability of each sales channel.

In-house delivery gives you more control

With your own drivers, you have more control over the customer relationship. You choose your delivery area, operating hours, estimated times, how orders are handed over and the level of service you want to provide.

You also have more control over your brand identity. The customer orders directly from you, receives your packaging and stays within your own brand environment.

This can be particularly valuable for a pizzeria that already has a loyal local customer base and a regular volume of delivery orders.

But it requires real organisation

In-house delivery is not simply about finding someone with a scooter.

You need to manage schedules, absences, quiet periods and peak times, possible vehicles, insurance, equipment, safety, maintenance and staff-related costs.

You also need to coordinate departures so that a driver does not leave with one order while two more are almost ready for the same area.

Poorly organised in-house delivery can quickly become expensive and disrupt the entire pizzeria.

Order volume is a key factor

If you only have a few deliveries each evening, employing or assigning a dedicated driver can be difficult to make profitable.

On the other hand, with a high and regular volume, bringing delivery in-house can become much more attractive.

The calculation should therefore be based on your real activity: how many deliveries per hour, what average distance, how many orders per trip and how much time is each driver genuinely occupied?

Do not think only in terms of number of orders. Think in terms of real cost per delivery.

Delivery platforms make it easier to get started

Delivery platforms allow you to offer delivery quickly without immediately building an entire logistics operation.

They may provide access to their own driver network, manage part of the ordering process and give your pizzeria visibility among customers who may not already know you.

For a new establishment or a pizzeria that wants to test demand for delivery, this can be a simple way to start.

You can observe whether customers genuinely order for delivery before investing more heavily in your own system.

But that convenience comes at a cost

Delivery platforms usually charge commissions or other fees that can represent a significant share of the order value.

A pizza that is profitable when sold directly can therefore become much less attractive once platform fees are deducted.

You need to calculate profitability by sales channel.

A €25 order placed directly with your pizzeria and a €25 order placed through a platform do not necessarily generate the same margin.

Do not look only at turnover

Seeing several thousand euros of monthly sales coming through a delivery platform can make the channel look extremely successful.

But that figure needs to be analysed after commissions, promotions that may be partly funded by the pizzeria, packaging costs, production time and other expenses linked to the order.

What matters is not only the additional turnover.

What matters is how much is actually left for the pizzeria after the order has been processed.

Platforms can bring in new customers

One of their main advantages is their audience.

Someone opening a delivery app may not be looking for your pizzeria specifically. They may simply be searching for “pizza”.

Your establishment can therefore appear in front of customers who might never have discovered you otherwise.

This can be especially useful when launching a pizzeria or operating in a highly competitive area.

But the customer relationship belongs less directly to the pizzeria

When a customer orders through a platform, a large part of their experience takes place within that platform’s environment.

They may remember that they ordered “through the app” rather than directly from your establishment.

You also generally have less control over the commercial relationship and less access to customer data.

This is one of the biggest differences compared with an order placed directly through your own website.

The platform also places you directly beside competitors

On a delivery platform, your pizzeria appears alongside many other restaurants.

Customers can quickly compare prices, ratings, delivery times and promotions.

They may order from you today and from a competitor tomorrow simply because the competitor appears higher in the app or is offering a discount.

The visibility provided by platforms can therefore be useful, but it also comes with immediate competition.

Be careful about dependency

A delivery platform can be useful, but becoming too dependent on a single intermediary can make your business more vulnerable.

Changes in commission rates, algorithms, visibility or commercial conditions can have a significant impact on your turnover.

It is therefore often better to consider a platform as one sales channel among several, rather than the only way customers can reach your pizzeria.

In-house delivery can encourage direct ordering

With your own delivery service, you can naturally direct customers towards your website or phone line.

You have greater control over the ordering journey, promotions, loyalty programme and communication.

Over time, this can help build a more direct relationship with your customers.

But again, this independence only makes sense if the system remains profitable.

Calculate the real cost of an in-house driver

To compare both options properly, you need to know the real cost of your own delivery operation.

This may include wages, staff-related charges depending on the country, insurance, vehicle costs or reimbursements, maintenance, fuel or electricity, equipment and the time during which the driver is available but not actively delivering.

Then divide that total cost by the actual number of deliveries completed.

You can then compare this figure with the fees charged by delivery platforms.

Consider the density of your delivery area

A dense city and a rural area cannot be managed in the same way.

If several orders can be delivered within a few kilometres, an in-house driver may complete many deliveries in a short period.

If every order requires fifteen or twenty minutes of travel in a different direction, profitability can become much more difficult.

The geography of your customer base is therefore almost as important as the number of orders.

Define a realistic delivery area

The larger your delivery area, the more customers you can theoretically reach.

But longer distances also mean longer transport times and a greater risk that the quality of the pizza will deteriorate.

A pizza arriving after forty-five minutes of transport may no longer represent the experience you want customers to associate with your pizzeria.

Your delivery area should therefore be defined according to both profitability and product quality on arrival.

Your pizza must be suitable for delivery

Not every pizza handles transport in the same way.

Some very moist or particularly delicate recipes can lose quality quickly inside a box.

Before developing delivery on a large scale, test your pizzas after 10, 20 or 30 minutes of transport.

Check the base, cornicione, temperature, toppings and condensation.

The question is not simply: “Can I deliver this pizza?” It is: “Am I happy for my customer to discover my pizza in this condition?”

Packaging becomes even more important

For delivery, the box needs to cope with stacking, movement and sometimes longer transport times.

Sauces need secure lids, desserts need to remain stable and drinks may need to be separated properly.

A good driver cannot compensate for poor packaging.

The quality of the customer experience at home therefore depends heavily on the packaging you choose.

Delivery times need to remain realistic

Whether delivery is handled internally or through a platform, the customer mainly judges the final result: the order should arrive within a reasonable time and in good condition.

Avoid overly optimistic promises.

If the kitchen already needs thirty minutes to prepare the order before a driver can even leave, promising delivery in twenty minutes is impossible.

It is better to quote fifty minutes and arrive in forty-five than promise thirty and arrive after an hour.

Pay attention to when the driver is called

An order should not sit in its box for twenty minutes waiting for a driver to become available.

Production and delivery need to be coordinated.

With an in-house team, you can control departure timing more directly.

With a platform, the process depends more heavily on the system and driver availability.

In both cases, the objective is the same: reduce the time between the pizza leaving the oven and reaching the customer.

Reviews can be affected by delivery problems you do not fully control

With a platform, customers may sometimes associate a poor delivery experience with your restaurant even when the delay was not directly caused by your team.

A cold pizza, a shaken-up order or an excessive delay can damage the perception of your business.

This is an important limitation: part of the customer experience is being handed over to a third party.

That does not mean platforms should be avoided, but the risk should be part of your decision.

You can use a hybrid model

The choice does not have to be strictly “in-house or platform”.

Some pizzerias use both.

For example, in-house delivery may cover a nearby area for direct customers, while a platform is used to reach a wider zone or handle certain peaks.

You can also start with a platform and gradually develop your own delivery service once the volume becomes high enough.

A hybrid model can provide useful flexibility.

Your own website can create a third option

It may also be possible to use your own ordering system while outsourcing only the delivery part to an external provider, depending on what services are available in your area.

This allows you to keep more control over the order and customer relationship without necessarily employing your own drivers.

This option can be attractive, but it still needs to be compared financially with the other models.

Think about kitchen capacity before expanding delivery

Adding another sales channel does not automatically create additional production capacity.

If your kitchen is already saturated with dine-in and takeaway orders between 7:30 p.m. and 9 p.m., opening delivery widely may simply increase delays.

Before looking for more orders, make sure your team can produce them.

Delivery needs to be included in your overall capacity alongside dine-in, phone and online orders.

You can limit delivery during critical periods

You do not always need to offer exactly the same delivery service throughout the day.

Depending on the system you use, you may be able to reduce the delivery area, increase estimated times or temporarily suspend certain orders when production is saturated.

This control is important to prevent delivery from negatively affecting every other customer.

Accepting one extra order is not worthwhile if it delays ten others.

Compare every channel using the same indicators

To understand what is genuinely working, regularly compare:

  • turnover generated;
  • average order value;
  • delivery cost;
  • commissions and fees;
  • packaging cost;
  • production time;
  • any promotions;
  • mistakes and refunds;
  • and above all, the real margin achieved.

A channel generating less turnover may sometimes be significantly more profitable.

Negotiate when your volume increases

If a platform represents a significant volume for your establishment, commercial conditions may sometimes change depending on the provider, market and contract.

Do not automatically assume that your initial terms must remain the same forever.

Likewise, if you manage delivery internally, regularly look for hidden costs and opportunities to optimise routes.

Delivery should be monitored like any other important area of business management.

Check the rules that apply in your country

Employing drivers, using vehicles, insurance requirements, employment law, safety obligations and certain rules relating to delivery platforms can vary between European countries.

If you create your own delivery service, check the local obligations that apply to your situation.

Do not build your business model around assumptions about staffing costs or employment status without checking the rules that actually apply in your country.

Start small if you are unsure

You do not need to decide from day one that you will cover the entire city with five drivers.

You can start with a small delivery area, certain services or one single channel.

Then measure order volumes, travel times, customer feedback and profitability.

You can expand gradually using real data rather than assumptions.

In summary

In-house delivery gives you greater control over the customer experience, your brand and the commercial relationship, but it requires sufficient volume, strong organisation and precise cost management.

Delivery platforms make it easier to get started, provide visibility and remove the need to manage all logistics directly, but their fees can significantly reduce margins and the customer relationship remains more dependent on an intermediary.

You do not necessarily need to choose one model permanently. A hybrid approach may be appropriate depending on your activity.

The right decision should be based on your numbers: order volume, distances, real cost per delivery, commissions, production capacity and the quality of the pizza when it arrives.

The best delivery system is not the one that lets you travel the furthest or accept the most orders. It is the one that allows you to deliver a pizza that is still good, within a controlled timeframe, while keeping enough margin.